How we verify impact
Every number a founder shares shows how well it's been checked. It moves up a level as documents are added and looked at. When a number changes, the founder updates it and we keep the earlier version.
Self-reported
The founder has shared the number, but nothing that supports it yet.
It comes with a definition and a period, but no document is attached.
Backed
The founder has shared a document that supports it.
For example a payroll extract, a transaction export or a partner letter. Nobody has checked it yet.
Spot-checked
A lead from the startup's chapter has looked at that document and agrees it holds up.
A City Chapter Lead or Community & Programmes Lead can ask the founder for more documents first. Leads never check a startup they own.
Audited
The Builders Circle team has checked it in depth, independently of the founder.
It is the highest level. A figure can be audited straight from Backed or after a spot-check, so it needn't climb every step.
The founder, their chapter's leads and the Builders Circle team can open the documents. So can an audit firm during an audit, and subscribers the founder shares a document with. Founders and mentors in the chapter see each figure's level, and the public sees only figures that are Backed or higher.
How the score works
Each startup gets an Integrity score from 0 to 100, made of four parts. It counts active claims only: drafts and claims that were restated or withdrawn don't count, and a startup with no active claims isn't scored.
Evidenceup to 40 points
How well the claims are backed. Each claim earns a share of these points: none when Self-reported, half when Backed, more when Spot-checked and all of it when Audited.
Consistencyup to 25 points
Starts full and loses 10 points for each high flag and 5 for each warning flag that is open, awaiting a decision or upheld.
Freshnessup to 20 points
The share of claims added or confirmed as still accurate in the last 6 months.
Correction behaviourup to 15 points
Starts at 10. Each claim the founder restates or withdraws themselves in the last year adds 2.5, up to 15. Corrections made after a flag was upheld don't count.
We compute an Integrity score for each startup from its impact claims. The startup's founders and the Builders Circle team can see it, and so can subscribers once the founder shares the startup with them. Founders can see exactly how it is calculated.